So, what is actually "sloppy"? The shifter arm itself where it bolts to the shifter linkage? There is supposed to be quite a bit of play there. My Hurst pistol grip wiggles probably 2" in any direction in any gear. The shifter arm is a solid bar, so that ain't got too much slop in it. I like my Hurst and all, but if it were my '68, I'd stick with the Inland shifter since it came that way. Now, if the slop is in the shifter linkage, then maybe these other guys here are right. I think the '69 cars had Hurst linkages with Inland shifters & that would be a piece of cake swap. I don't know much about Inland shifters, but are those three nuts tight? Is there some kind of rubber biscuit or something below those nuts that could wear out? Is there a way for you to add a couple washers or something simple to the connection between the shifter & the linkage to take out some of the slop? Just thinkin'.....