ok update time. I wound up staying over at work today and (again) re doing a job I paid someone else to do.... NEVER FREAKING FAILS. Every time I pay like a "regular" person to "have" anything done, I end up having to redo their work.
I have better news (yawn, sorry guys) I got them balanced MUCH better, than what I had paid to have done. Definitely more livable, believeable. and none had the horrible "out of round" the owner of the tire shop claimed...... he says he stopped recommending US Wheels, because he has had many with this "problem". and asked me more than once, how much genuine Cragars would have cost.......
I have had several Dakotas. All with 15" wheels/tires. so I took the 3 new wheels/tires that took the ungodly amounts of weight and one of my "saves" from my 92 Dakota (kept as "spares" for my '99) to work and kept the balancer busy for a while. I balanced the Dakota wheel/tire as was and stepped back and watched it spin, had a little side to side but took 2-1/2 oz total to balance.
-- I then spun the new wheel/tire that had the most weight (2 layers of stick on that extended 1/2 way a round behind the spokes plus 6 oz pounded on the inside lip.
It was only 1/4 oz off in that configuration, did not spin as poorly (wobble/out of round) as I was led to believe.
--I scraped off and peeled off 14 oz of weight, hit the "SPIN" and it asked for ~4 oz of weight total. I didn't put on weight it asked for.
--I then deflated that tire and broke the bead, spun the tire on the rim and put it back on the balancer, I had marked the tire pos. related to stem before the breakdown. The weight called for was still significantly less tahn the tire shop had on it but still more than Id liked. the weight position also had shifted. (if it was all "wheel" the weight asked-for position would have been much the same as what the tire shop had done).
--I demounted that tire and the Dakota tire, swapped the new tire off the jeg's wheel and the 1/2 used one from the Dakota wheel, spun them.
The new tire on the Dakota wheel, had about the same amount of side to side in it, as the Dakota wheel did with the old tire. (which wasn't much, maybe 1/8" oscillation. Ive seen worse. And no "hop" up n down. ) And asked for the same amount of weight, within 1/4 oz as that wheel with its original tire.
--I then put the new tire back on its same rim the tire shop mounted it to. and rebalanced it. I broke it down and spun the tire one more time, got it down to 2 oz total weight needed. A far cry from 14.
-- I then spun each of the other 2 wheel/tire combos, all took much less than tire shop had put on but still more than I like to see in anything less than a Semi truck tire. I broke the 2nd tire down, spun tire and reseated it once, came out the worst of the 3 that I took in, at 3 oz total. and no wobble/hop. Spun very true.
the last one took 3 breakdowns/spin/reinflate cycles to get it to its best, which I got down to 1-1/2 oz total weight required. It started with about 12 oz of weight.
But, by doing nothing but scraping off the tire shop's weights and spinning on balancer, none of the wheels I took in and redid, called for more than half of what the tire shop had pounded/stuck onto my wheels. and that was before I broke them down and spun any tire in relation to wheel.
One thing I learned long ago, and it was insisted upon by the owners of the shop I worked at many jobs ago and 25 years ago....
DON'T just pound the weights on as the machine says.... STEP BACK and watch the wheels and tires spin, and regardless of weight called for, put the best, truest spinning ones on the front and if any have any "wobble" put on the back, or if bad enough, replace. most shops DO NOT do this. any that call for a ridiculous amount, go get another from the stockroom and try again. usually (somehow?) that tire that called for ridiculous weight, wants a "normal" amount on the next guy's car. Not always though, but when it does, it's really weird that way.
this place came to me VERY highly recommended, always hear great things, even my son buys all his tires there and takes anything I can't handle (I don't have an alignment machine for instance) and anything he needs "NOW" that I don't have time to give that kind of attention to, he takes there and always seems happy with their work (He invited the owner and his wife to his wedding even) They have done a couple of alignments for me and I haven't had an issue there. And having been an alignment guy myself for 20+ years I think that says something....... before I found them Ive had to pay 2x for an alignment on more than 1 vehicle since I left the alignment shop and lost my access to do my own.......