How do you lose something that big? Carriers were and still are today the most important battle platforms in war. I doubt if it was really lost. After the Japanese sank it we replaced it with another one with the same name. That probably scared the hell out of them. A lot of things that were deemed negative towards the war effort were not allowed to be in the news thanks to FDR'S war powers act. I can't believe that a carrier with all of its aircraft and support ships could just be lost with no one involved on either side reporting it's whereabouts. My guess is that it's location fell victim to war propaganda.
Correct, not to mention even as big as the Hornet was it didn't sink 3 miles straight down , it probably driffed for a mile or so.I'm gonna say that when enemy bullets are coming at you, and your shipmates are dead or dying, your ship is sinking...marking down the exact location of a sinking ship headed for a three mile trip down isn't exactly a priority.....and yeah...during WWll...people did and were told to keep their months shut, unlike today when there are millions of cell phones taking video. Imagine trying to pull off D Day in this day and age.....
And sad to say not taught in our schools any more.Tombs of true heroes, a debt for which we can never repay.
Im sure that they had a pretty good idea of it's location. It's not like losing your car keys. At 20,000 tons that's a pretty big chunk of iron. It wasn't in an area where it could be salvaged or recovered by the enemy. Public moral was critical and our secrets were safe at that depth. Also it didn't sink immediately. After the morning attack it's fires were extinguished but it was dead in the water. The Northampton CA-26 even had her in tow for an hour before the second attack which was in the afternoon. At that point she had listed to 18 degrees and the decision was made to abandon her. I still think it was for propaganda that her location was kept secret.