Depending on RPM it's possible to see 50 and 32, but it would have to be running fairly fast.
It really should not change much when the vacuum advance is connected or disconnected, maybe just speed up or slow down a bit.
If it was still running at a fairly high RPM, then the mechanical advance was adding timing and you still really don't know where the initial is.
I would suggest pulling the plugs, check the timing while cranking so you can get an initial. That being said we are assuming the TDC mark on the harmonic balancer is correct. Did you get to check the step up rods in the carb? Still the same issue with lack of fuel?