That Cummins has considerably MORE towing capacity than the 6.4 Hemi.
Admittedly, the 6.4 gasser "can" tow as much as most people need - but it's like drum brakes on our classics. They do the job...but nothing in reserve in case its needed. And the delta from empty to towing 10k lbs for my Cummins is about 2mpg; a gasser, it's more like a 12-15mpg drop when you load it up.
The Cummins is MASSIVELY detuned for the pickups, which is why they last forever. Mine has nearly 300k on it and I still get 18mpg towing 10k lbs...and the truck doesn't even know its there. Boost runs a little higher...EGTs are a couple hundred hotter...I have to actually use first gear at stop signs...and that's about it.
The diesel carries a premium, sure...but you get every cent back at resale (
if you ever sell it - but after living with one for a while, chances are it'll be the last truck you want to own). 2G Rams like mine run about $5k for a gasser right now; comparable trucks with the Cummins (especially with the stick shift) are 5
times that, regardless of miles. Fuel cost is about the same, dollars per
mile, once you factor in the fuel economy savings, even with diesel as much as $1.25 more per gallon than regular. And, lower maintenance - no plugs, no wires, oil change every 5k, fuel filter every 10k, air filter when it gets dirty, and a valve lash adjustment every 24k. Woo. Hoo.
On my 300k 2001, I've done regular maintenance. The "extra" stuff? One belt tensioner and belt, around 225k. One water pump, around 235k (likely damaged by the belt tensioner locking up, and eating the wp bearing). A clutch at 250k. And the achilles' heel of the 24v, I replaced the electric fuel lift pump with a mechanical one at around 210k as a preventative measure. When the stock lift pump loses pressure, the high pressure injection pump starves, overheats, and locks up - to the tune of about $2400 in parts. If you get a second-gen with the 24v...change the pump, and install a fuel pressure gauge. Worth their weight in gold. Earlier 12v engines, and later engines, don't have this issue - but there are dozens of options to upgrade this setup (FASS, Glacier Diesel, etc).
While I love the new engine and its specs...you can't get a manual trans anymore. I'll stick with my six speed 2001.5 (rear disc brakes), and keep after the rust monster. Anyone in Maryland wanna tack on a set of cab corners and outer rockers for me? One thing I never learned how to do was weld.....