You must remember the axle bearings are NOT lubed by differential lube. They must be hand packed.If you have a new foam gasket, use it. You could also use some grease and gear oil high temp sealer. A small amount of sealer on the other gasket would not hurt. If the wheel bearings are saturated with gear oil, I would let them drip dry and then repack as best you can with a needle grease gun.
Mike