LOL... what did he expect ??, just smell that stuff, you can't get it even close to your nose without gaging... You know I love my dog, I don't own any cats, we had them when I was younger, I don't have one mostly because, I can't stand the smell of litter-boxes either, go into anyone's house who owns a cat & you can tell immediately... But between them always barfing, gagging &/or spitting up hairballs all over, that should be a pretty good clue, cat food is rancid stuff.... Just for the sake of curiosity, I always wondered what "Buddies" Puperroni Treats tasted like, they really smell & look just like a real beef jerky stick, like you get @ 7-11, probably the same thing in them jars...LOL... but I ain't going to be taste testing his food anytime soon...