All my racecars have had a return style regulator
we always set them flowing never had any issues
far less heat in the pumps too, my 6.69 @ 217 T/S
or my old 68 RR went 8.58 @156, to my street/strip cars
anything with carburetors
(My mentality or thinking, I took it out of the mech. FI playbook
(even the newest & state of the art latest EFI or direct injection does too)
feed it way more than it will even use, always have enough on hand
& always bypassing off the fuel/fuel it couldn't use, send it back to the tank,
like most all real fast professional racecars fuel systems are, was my thinking)
sorry
that sounded a bit condescending, it wasn't meant to be
I've used it in many different pump combos
CNC P/S pump 500+gpm, Magnafuel to old Barry Grant style pumps
even the ol' dual Holley Blue 110 (or red) Black 120-150 pumps
all have had a bypass style regulator, sending unused fuel back to tank/cell
electric pumps seem to last longer, not deadheading them
even on all my N2O systems, I have used the bypass style regulators
flowing pressure is better, in my experience
Your results may vary
Obviously, some others may have a different take &/or opinions on it
or maybe think it's overkill, or it's not necessary
But;
I find something that works & I stick with it...
My current street/strip car, street-beast
more of corner carver in search of a straightaway
has an
Aeromotive SS 175gph 1/2" or #8AN feed/draw
drawn thru an Aeromotive 100 micron canister style filter
up in the shock well
feeding a 1/2" or #8AN line to the pump down near the pass side frame rail
down by the leaf springs sort of, line out of it,
all the way to front of the car
to a Holley (was Aeromotive) bypass style regulator
then a 10-micron inline filter, before the #6AN feeding the 6bbl
with a 1/4" or #4AN return all the way back to the tank
thru the center of the org, style 1/2" MRE sending unit,
where the vapor return line org. was, dumps it back into the tank
(haven't noticed any aeration or loss of pressure)
I didn't want to cut the car or put a cell in it
so it has a stock type fuel tank
It's not an ideal set up for a racecar,
it's not a whole lot different other than cell vs tank
but for what I'm doing it's great
made quite a few passes WOT, long, long wide-open stretches
& TNT drag tests too
it didn't & hasn't fluctuated at all
had 7psi all the way from idle to 6,200
(more the Hyd Roller cam limitation, it will pull to 7,000)
it's been trouble-free since 2005
except for the Aeromotive bypass-reg messed up, after 10 years
for some reason, I didn't take it apart to see why
I just installed a Holley bypass one I had on the shelf,
was back up running
I hope some of that helps