I just did a search for the area and there are three cars for sale in the area.
- The one on LI that your looking at. Looks like a pretty good original car. I watched this in eBay twice and it didn't sell. It got to just over $27k both times. All I can say is - that's what the car is worth IMO, minus a few %. I never saw this one in person but I would guess it's a bit rougher in person than in pictures.
- EE1 White top car in NJ. This is the car that's listed here too. $35k but he said he's motivated. I saw this car in person and it pretty darn nice. I don't think this car could possibly need anything.
- Saw a Maroon car at AACA in Hershey and it's now on eBay. At Hershey it was FS@$29k. Obviously it did not sell. I did not look under the hood but the paint was okay but thin in spots and interior was good. Car is in the Harrisburg area. Another good original car. eBay pictures it looks like the aircleaner is wrong but otherwise okay. 1 day left of bidding and it did not break $20k.
What did we learn? Well, I'm not sure but I believe that you should always buy the best car possible based on what's available at the time. Money is always an issue but all three of these are close in money. If I were you I would try like hell to buy the EE1 white top car in NJ if you like the look. Those other two cars are $25k and that's about it IMO. Maybe a little more if you 'have to have it'.
Only reason I would be hesitant to buy the blue car at $29k is because eBay proved it wasn't worth that. I would always feel like I paid too much. My justification with spending in the past was - if I paid that much for it, chances are some else would too. If you labor over the decision too long it will consume you.