I'm 5'7" and 148 lbs. I went to one of the high end runners footwear stores and had my feet measured and my foot-fall and gait examined before they told me I have neither over pronation or supination and recommended a neutral shoe. But I am a heal striker when I walk and run. Then they brought me Saucony, New Balance and Hoka. I went home with a pair of Saucony Guide 17 but after a few partial days I will be returning them because of the rocker design of the outsole. I almost fell over backwards when I tried them on and thought I'd get used to them.
I'm looking at Topo Athletic 5mm drop running shoes and will try them on. I've tried zero drop shoes like the Altra Lone Peak 7 but they hurt my Achilles tendon and calf muscles. My daughter and son-in-law and 3 grandkids love zero drop shoes. I did like the wide toe box of the Altras.
You are much lighter then me. but I think tis applies a bit yet...
Look at ESOXER's picture of the boot there.
now, look at JUST the leather part. See how it looks like a sock?
All they did was take the natural shape of a foot, wrap leather on it.
Then whatever they put on the bottom is dependent on purpose.
Maybe you wouldn't like the heel, maybe you would find it nice. Not that you want to go jogging in boots, but for walking/hiking the first thing to look at is the shape of the upper and how it is attached to the bottom.
Modern tennis shoes have gone all "one up" on each other claiming all these crazy foam rubber shapes are the next best thing.
It is ALL BS, science has proven the goof *** shaped mega heel, round bottom shoes designed for jogging created more foot issues then any type of benefit to impact reduction could have been.
you want a sole on the bottom big enough to be stable but not too big or it is clumsy and WILL affect how you land your step.
my favorite running shoes I ever had was a pair of $14 Avia's i got at a shoe clearance place. They were a synthetic leather upper with mesh spots on the side and over the toe, the heel bulged out just a little(like your foot does) and I mean the leather part not the bottom rubber part, and the bottom was just a plain rubber with some foam above it for cushion. No crazy mega arches, curved bottoms, super wide area under the ball of my foot, crazy giant heels. It was like an ankle high sock with some foam rubber on the bottom and a strap of tread rubber on that. They were the lightest shoes I think I have ever owned, had the right arch support(on the insole) and were breathable. Lasted about 3 years.
I recommend if you want a tennis shoe, you look for the most normal looking shoe you can find, see if it looks like a sock glued onto some foam, and make sure it breaths. Then so long as the arch is in the right spot I bet they are perfect.
Everything I describe above is why people find stuff like thorogoods comfy to hike around in all day. It is a leather sock on top of some cork(or foam) with a rubber bottom stitched on(maybe neoprene). Once the leather softens and finds it's spot shaped like your foot, it really is a leather sock with a bottom attached.