Dibbons
Well-Known Member
- Local time
- 12:24 AM
- Joined
- Nov 29, 2014
- Messages
- 4,844
- Reaction score
- 5,730
- Location
- La Paz, B.C.S., Mexico
(Times are from MSP tests.)
I don't know what is meant by "MSP test"?
(Times are from MSP tests.)
Michigan State Police.I don't know what is meant by "MSP test"?
Roger Huntington was a famous auto writer/tester from the sixties and seventies who did testing on the muscle cars of the day, using a fifth wheel I believe. He was sure many of the muscle cars of the day were under rated by rating their horsepower at a lower rpm than actual peak. His list of top 10 underrated were all bigblocks but he did have a number for 340 4bbl.
340 factory 275 @5000
Real 320 @ 5600
Unfortunately he didn't test the 340 sixpack.
Below are excerpts from his top ten list, rated first, then his calculated. ( the whole list is posted on fabo under the title " real horsepower of muscle cars" from 2010)
#8 440 magnum 375 @4600, 410 @5400
#4 440 6 pack 390 @ 4700, 430 @5600
#2 hemi 425 @5000, 470 @6000.
Number one was the L88/ZL1 (big surprise) and the list included just about every hipo big block from the big three.
To me, the most comical was the 390/428 cj from ford. The 390 was a complete dog, rated at 335hp, ruined by 396 chevelles, and destroyed by roadrunners. But the 428cj was rated at the exact same 335hp, and was very competitive with any but the very top tier of muscle car.
Trying to lower car insurance rates! Quid pro quo.That's interesting. Magazine track test results from back in the day show the opposite.
It made 338HP
But only 394 Torque?
Down from claimed 420ft lbs, I wonder why?
Actually, I don't think so. I think this, like other formula that I know more about, are net-actual flywheel hp (verses gross-corrected flywheel hp from an engine dyno). Net actual can look a lot like RWHP, depending on several factors.
I see it as a marketing ploy. I've noticed that Ma Mopar usually ended their ratings in a 0 or a 5 most of the time: 230, 235, 275, 290, 300, 330, 335, 350, 375, 390, 425.But why would anyone OVERRATE?
The Mexican version of the 318 according to the bill of my car is 270 hp, as far as I know they use here 340 cilynder heads, forge crankshaft, and a four barrel carburetor, only for reference of course.What is interesting is the 318 and 340, in chart #1 318 goes from 230 to 150, 340 is 275 to 250.
But on clayton chassis dyno, the 318 is 85RWHP, and the 340 is ONLY 90RWHP??
Once again that magical 5hp number pops up, LOL.
Could exhaust manifolds, strangle the 318 that much vs the 340?
So with the hot rod mag test dyno tests, the Roger Huntington tests, and the Steve Magnante 340 tests data
We know the 383 RR/Magnum is rated correct at 335HP
The Hemi is rated correct for RPM, but UNDER RATED and can produce 465-500hp @6,000
The 340HP4bbl is under rated and makes 320HP
The 340 6Bbl 356HP@5,500 and 382tq@4000rpm
The 440 Magnum is VERY close to rated HP, coming in at 360HP(but with headers and a larger carb it makes 420HP)
Info sourced from
440:
https://www.hotrod.com/articles/mopp-0104-buildup-1969-440-magnum-engine/#:~:text=Further in the Chrysler performance literature, the "Bracket,four barrels at a more conservative 330 hp.
383:
https://www.hotrod.com/articles/mopp-0209-383-engine-restore/
340-4bbl/340-6bbl
https://www.hotrod.com/articles/bad-mopars-340-beat-ford-chevy-shocking-new-data/
You're certainly entitled to choose to believe what you like. There are well established relationships between car weight and trap speed mph. The HP numbers stated simply don't line up with the cars weight and trap speed. Long ago I dug up probably 15 historic track tests and compiled the data in a spread sheet. The HP numbers from that were way lower than advertised.
Also, it looks like you're not interested in what Chrysler said the real HP numbers were from their engines from the factory. It's in their Chassis or Engine manual.
500 HP hemi don't run 105 mph in the 1/4 mi. and a 370 HP 440 don't run 98 mph.
They were running those tests on bias ply tires, put on a set of radials bet times improve.