New post because I'm still dealing with this. Is it possible what I think is detonation, beginning at 2k RPM could be valvetrain noise? Loose lifter(s)? I just got done driving the car and the AFRs are in the 11s with timing at 29* at 2k RPM. It's rattling like nobody's business as soon as I hit 2k RPM, which is why I assumed it was detonation. But... it's pretty loud and starting to sound mechanical, possibly getting louder (I haven't driven the car in a while, so maybe it's noisier because I haven't heard it for some time).
I marked the balancer when the piston hit the stop, in both directions, and noticed the OEM timing mark is not in the middle. I have a paint spot next to the timing mark on the block. The paint and OEM mark are about the same distance away from each other as the balancer mark is from where it should be, if that makes sense. So... whomever built the engine looks to have made the paint mark the "new" TDC. I set the timing mark on the balancer to that paint spot.
I have a Mallory distributor. The "eye" lined up perfectly with one of the gaps in the rotor, per instructions. The rotor was pointed at my #1 plug wire.
All seems to be correct.
Timing at idle is 10* with 29* at 2k RPM.
I do not believe the car is running out-of-the-ordinary compression and is using 87oct pump gas (same as I've always run).
Fueling is a Sniper 2 (which is working perfectly).
Car never had this problem until I swapped from an OEM coil to an Accel (I didn't know they weren't compatible). Since then, I've had this problem, even after swapping back to the OEM coil.
If this is valvetrain, then that's a hilarious coincidence, that's sent me down this rabbit hole.
To reiterate: engine is a 440 of unknown year, stock heads. Mallory Unilite dist.