• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Looking for insurance on a near completed car, what to look for?

69 GTX

FBBO Gold Member
FBBO Gold Member
Local time
12:33 AM
Joined
Apr 6, 2013
Messages
7,159
Reaction score
7,139
Location
Milo, Iowa
I got a scare Monday as a tornado went by my pace about 5 miles south. All I could think of was my car. So I'm wondering what's the best option till I get it on the road. Has anyone ever had a claim on their car before it was finished and how do you rate them? Thanks!
 
Hagerty offers agreed value on resto projects. Call them. Little pricey to me tho at 300 a year for agreed value 30,000 on project car
 
Grundy is way cheaper than Hagerty, same thing, never had a claim
 
Grundy is way cheaper than Hagerty, same thing, never had a claim
I just checked on coverage for mine and Grundy was 1/2 of what Hagarty wanted. I think both had options to increase coverage as needed too.
 
You might need an appraiser look at the car. Depending on the value. If you have a pile of NOS parts don't forget them.
 
Grundy may. be cheaper but I can only attest to what I have personal experience with.
 
Hagerty was 379$ for 40000 of coverage for 12 months. That is not coverage for anything that can be driven, that would of been 750$+ I'll check grundy
 
I have Chubb. No mileage restrictions and 50k stated value. Don't know if they need it on the road or not.
 
This is very interesting. I have Hagerty and have no complaints, though I have never had a claim (other than calling for a tow one time). I was unaware of Grundy, but I think I'll look into them when my policy comes due again in Dec.. Half of what Hagerty charges is too good not to.
 
Last edited:
I use J.C Taylor, they require an appraisal with pictures for insured value coverage. I am paying $525 a year for 65K coverage, and yes, that's what the appraiser came up with for coverage as my car rated #1 except a couple of things that were #2. Also required to be garage kept, and no racing at the track!
 
I was with Hagerty for years, and they kept raising my rates, as I live in New York. I inquired about the rate increases, and it turns out they were because they paid out so much in claims for Hurricane Sandy that hit NYC, and New Jersey, that even though I live near Buffalo, we were in the same area as the damage occurred ? That was the end with them, and I switched to Heacock, who is at Carlisle every year. It turned out I insured all 4 of my classics, for less than the price I was paying for my '70 Challenger, which is a very nice, high end resto. I would recommend to anyone in the market for Classic insurance, and they are pretty easy to deal with...

100_2055.JPG
 
Plenty of good choices out there. I have Condon and Skelly for agreed amount at $50k coverage. They want pics and the car has to be garaged. Pretty normal for classic car coverage. I'm paying $284 + $49 for the roadside assistant package. I'm in SoCal which is a pretty high theft market - with Mexico right down the freeway and all. I'm an insurance professional and think that's a pretty good deal for a very reputable company.
 
Different people have different experiences. Just call of the few companies noted here & go with what you like.
 
Agreed value. I use J C Taylor in Upper Darby, Pa. No claim experience though.
 
Remember I'm asking for coverage of a nonrunning project. Grundy will not insure anything that is not running. Anyone else have a company they insured their car with before it hit the road? I actually thought Hagerty's price was pretty reasonable. 379$ is just barley over a dollar a day.
 
Home owner's insurance, or renter's insurance should cover it if anything were to happen to it while physically on your property. Talk to your agent...

Also: Make a photo or video diary of your car and parts. It would be priceless should you need to prove you had what you claim you had.
 
i was able to put my gtx onto my regular statefarm and it was waaaay cheaper then hagerty or grundy. i simply added it as a "stated value vehicle" i told them what i thought it was worth, as i work on it, i call them up and tell them to increase the value. never any inspections or pictures or anything. but that they know its a 68 gtx and my estimates arnt rediculous, if i wanted to tell them i thought it was worth 100k theyd obviously not agree. but it only costs me $10 a month and i have it valued at 10k right now. then when its on the road, i keep it at stated value so if something happens i get paid what i should, not what the computer calculates based on original MSRP and depreciation like they would a normal everyday car. the problem ive heard with those other classic car insurance companies is that as soon as you start enjoying it when you finish, say you have several nice days in a row, decide to take it to work a couple days, then you have an accident, they look at the odometer, see you drove it more then you were supposed to as a collectors car, and now they wont cover you. i called hagerty and grundy to get quotes and was asked how i use it, i said that i drive my monte carlo on nice days maybe to work once a week or so when its nice, and work is only 4.6 miles away. they said "no we cant cover you, we insurance collector cars you only go to shows with you drive on the weekends, youre not a good fit, and we wouldnt be able to cover you in a claim because the car wasnt used according to our terms. so make sure you look closely and realistically on how youll use it, because if that odometer is a mile too much for them, its possible you you wont be covered at all. this is simply based on my conversation with them regarding the plans i was looking at, may not be the exact case for everyone but my impression was if your not honest about how you use it, when the time comes god forbid to file a claim, its very possible you would be screwed, simply because you enjoy it and its not a trailer queen.
 
oh and then i only have one bill. its only 260/month for everything. home, 3 cars personal articles, guns, etc all insured with one bill. and if i add policies i get discounts on other ones.
 
Auto Transport Service
Back
Top