I am fairly certain the crank is smooth where the seal rides. This is the same crank that has been in the block for 7 years.Sucks about the rear main. I hate doing things twice which I am very familiar with lol.
I'm curious to know whether that new crank you have in the motor has the striations where the seal sits. It's suppose to direct the oil back to the motor while rotating. Or if the sealing surface o.d. of the crank is undersized. I've never used a non factory crank and issues like this have me think twice about building a stroker.