Nothing wrong with 9.6:1 compression, especially with aluminum heads. I suspect you are running a Holley carb? If so are your idle mixture screws responsive to adjustment? It could be that the front throttle blades are open too far and exposing too much of the transition slot, pulling in transition fuel at idle and producing a rich idle and too much air past the blades to allow the engine to shut off from idle when the kill is turned off. I won’t go into how to correct for that as it’s just speculation that you have a Holley and the front plates are opened too far.