This reminds me of the debates on the vintage snowmobile sites regarding Klotz/AMSoil/Castrol/whatever. At least you guys here are civil about it.
I've used Valvoline almost exclusively since 1972,running Max-Life in my '02 GMC truck(135,000+ miles) and the GF's '96 Park Avenue(120,000+ miles) with no problems except for some accelerated usage on the truck. The beater '90 Chevy truck has an ATK rebuild mill in it;used regular All-Climate to break it in(a couple of years ago;that oil may still have had some zinc in it) and am running Syn-Power in it now. Looks like I had better get a zinc additive in there as well,since it's a flat tappet mill. I'd better check the gf's Buick;some v-6's had flats,and some had roller lifters,and it's been awhile since I've worked with them so I may have lost the brain cells that remember when that transition took place...
When I got the Sport Fury home,first thing I did was change the oil in the 413 to 20W-50 VR1(10W-40 wasn't available,which I would have preferred for trying to start it in the winter while working on it);I didn't notice any mention of "off-road usage" on the container. Better check that as well...
This is a good thread,I hope it stays alive;lots of good info so far,and I'm sure more to come.