I guess it's a matter of perspective. For me it was a balancing act of budget vs. originality. Most of the parts that were replaced would have cost significantly more $$$ if the body shop was to repair them. Also, if I went the route of repairing severely damaged parts, there was always a chance the finished product would show minor imperfections after the paint was laid down. So it came down to what I could afford and what was important to me. The shop would have been more than happy for me to spend big $$$ repairing parts and what not, but it wasn't in my budget. They let me do a lot of work on the car at their place using their tools and supplies without charging me - this saved me quite a bit. If I had to do it all over again, I believe I would make the same choices.
Craig