j-c-c-62
Well-Known Member
In my younger days, this was a scenic view View attachment 1588073
Forget Peanuts or Tea, I'll take "Me"
Last edited:
In my younger days, this was a scenic view View attachment 1588073
Thkippy
The guy in the video in post #10 gives his opinion at minute 15:00 about the warning light. Go to 13:00 for the full explanation.How though is it possible the door plug could be related to these prior warning lights, meaning the cabin crew would never have heard any odd loud airstream noises in flight, like a passenger rolling down their window at altitude?
And if bolts indeed were missing, why did it take months for the plug to finally separate?
Not sure how many others feel this way, I pay little attention to nearby passengers in flight. If this event happened to me, my first thought would be after the plug left the airplane, somebody went out the hole, and I would have had that thought seared into my brain for over an hour? until we landed and learned officially otherwise.
I find both your above contentions implausible, mostly because the source of the potential leak noise source would be a point source in a long aircraft, easy to locate by anyone concerned or bothered and nearly every plane I have flown on since DC6's, one can carry on a normal conversation even with normal outside generated noise. If plane has prior pressurization difficulties, the inadvertent opening had to be somewhat substantial and loud, and at risk of oversimplification, it might be similar situation to the interior noise of a car driven at speed and the very noticeable increase in interior sound when any window is cracked only fractions of an inch.As far as not hearing it leaking, even with a large leak, it's hard to hear with all the other background noise inside the plane. Also it was behind insulation. If the leak was causing a seal to squeal, that would be about the only way to identify it from the inside with insulation in place.
The leaks are much easier to identify from the outside on the ground with the cabin pressurized with a ground air cart instead of the engines.
How though is it possible the door plug could be related to these prior warning lights, meaning the cabin crew would never have heard any odd loud airstream noises in flight, like a passenger rolling down their window at altitude?
And if bolts indeed were missing, why did it take months for the plug to finally separate?
Not sure how many others feel this way, I pay little attention to nearby passengers in flight. If this event happened to me, my first thought would be after the plug left the airplane, somebody went out the hole, and I would have had that thought seared into my brain for over an hour? until we landed and learned officially otherwise
Luckier still that the bolts were not a little bit stronger/tighter to allow the plane to get to higher altitude.Those passengers were so fortunate that happened at 16K feet likely with the seatbelt sign still on instead of 30K feet and folks walking about.
I agree after watching the video, but then that might suggest prior pressurization issues were unrelated to the door plug, or if the plug was the source, the leaks and noise were very short in nature as the plug bounced slightly on the hinge springs without any of the 4 bolts present?Watch the video in my Post #10 and the door/plug attachment is explained pretty thoroughly. Plus, there was likely little if any additional noise up to the point of separation.
I lean toward thinking a tech based company ought to have a tech based guy as a leader rather than an accountant.Boeing would be doing much better if it didn't have the idiot CEOs it has had in the last few years.
My statement is based on 20+ years working on airplanes and hundreds of hours fixing cabin air leaks.I find both your above contentions implausible, mostly because the source of the potential leak noise source would be a point source in a long aircraft, easy to locate by anyone concerned or bothered and nearly every plane I have flown on since DC6's, one can carry on a normal conversation even with normal outside generated noise. If plane has prior pressurization difficulties, the inadvertent opening had to be somewhat substantial and loud, and at risk of oversimplification, it might be similar situation to the interior noise of a car driven at speed and the very noticeable increase in interior sound when any window is cracked only fractions of an inch.
They do carry duct tape. This was on a UAL 747 half way to China a few years ago. A significant leak started a few hours into the flight.Why worry?
It's aircraft rated duct tape.
Well I base my contention on being a 5+ decade well respected audio engineer trained to listen well for anomalies that has spent thousands of hours in jet aircraft flying around the world that where not sitting on the ground being fixed for cabin air leaks.My statement is based on 20+ years working on airplanes and hundreds of hours fixing cabin air leaks.
Because in post 20 you asked how the crew couldn't hear an air leak. And I told you how. But you apparently didn't like my answer.Well I base my contention on being a 5+ decade well respected audio engineer trained to listen well for anomalies that has spent thousands of hours in jet aircraft flying around the world that where not sitting on the ground being fixed for cabin air leaks.
And all this matters really how?
Dude, stop polluting a serious safety issue for own personal agenda.Boeing CEO Assures Nervous Fliers That All 737 Aircraft Are Built To The Highest Diversity Standards
Jan 10, 2024
View attachment 1589395
SEATTLE, WA — Amid growing concerns over safety after several devastating mechanical failures on Boeing 737-9 Max aircraft, Boeing CEO Dave Calhoun assured hesitant travelers that all their aircraft are built according to the highest standards of diversity.
"I know everyone is nervous about the doors of their planes blowing off the aircraft mid-flight or the entire fuselage buckling due to faulty parts, but let me assure you: Boeing is diverse," said Calhoun in a CNBC interview. "In fact, our design and manufacturing crews are the most diverse in our company's history. Nothing to worry about."
Boeing is facing NTSB investigations after several mechanical failures that caused Alaska Airlines to ground all 737-9 Max aircraft. Calhoun said such concerns are unwarranted. "We have women, people of color, and even autistic paraplegics working on the 737," he said. "There's nothing safer than a plane built by diversity!"
At publishing time, 3 more airlines had grounded the aircraft, likely because they hate diversity.