Shorthorse
Well-Known Member
On the subject of T-stat's from what I've heard (some have posted) they have no influence on a car running hot unless it doesn't open or open fully. The gen idea is to get a faster warm up for those in the cold climates to get defrost/heat sooner, reach warm idle if you have such set up. (Mine's gone with headers) Once motor temp is up, it's up, T-stat means nada intense cold aside. Also some have opined to take it out when cold weather isn't a factor (stored winters). Mechanic buddy advised this isn't a good idea as the increase in flow through the rad is faster, gather more so with hi-flow pumps, where cooling is actually reduced as the rad can't do its job...
I agree with you about the thermostats job. I also agree with your buddy's assessment of whether to run a thermostat (or at least a restrictor) or not because I've experienced it first hand. Keep in mind this was on a race car. Had a 340 in one race car, six cylinder radiator, no thermostat, electric water pump, electric fan, no shroud and the car always ran cool (170-180 tops) no matter what the outside temp was. Put that same complete engine into another race car that previously had a 340, original radiator with a 160 thermostat which also cooled just fine. The newly swapped 340 ran hot and would not cool. We put a gutted thermostat in and everything returned to normal. This was just my personal experience and I don't know enough to explain the difference. As they say, "results may vary".