The point about old tires was not a matter of if it was a BFG tire. ALL tires are subject to the same thing. Mother Time. Just like a light bulb will work until it doesn't. Just because a tire has tread, looks good, balances well is all fine until it suddenly fails. I am sure there are plenty of Cooper stories out there as well.
What is sad is that all these "stories" are just like my dog is bigger than your dog..No point other than thinking you are different for some reason.
Just a heads up from someone who has had decades of real experience with many thousands of car tires. you guys have had experience with just a few. The numbers don't lie. Just be smart. Tires are made much better now than years ago. The good old days were not really that good for people that can remember that far back and not just regurgitate stories that have been passed down. Many so called "defects" are from lack of maintenance, impact damage, improper repairs etc... Tires are one of the most important things on a car. They are the only thing that lets a car accelerate or stop. " where the Rubber meets the road" is from an old Firestone Tire advertising campaign back in the sixties that says it all.
HP, Brake types don't matter if you don't have traction ( grip).
I was there and most of the tire business was in replacing tires that wore out in less than a year or belted tires whether they were bias belted or radial, fiberglass or steel or "Aramid". Poor traction, hard ride. BFG, Uni-Royal, Firestone, Goodyear, Dayton, Armstrong, Kelly-Springfield, Seiberling, Dunlop, Pirelli, and many others that had tread separations. The technology was not there yet.
Any of you guys in the tire business in the sixties or seventies know what I am talking about. Tire quality was poor compared to now. Michelin was the cream of the crop unless you got a flat. Liner damage after they went flat made most of them unrepairable, even with good tread. Retread business was real good back then.