Well, Bob, you can disagree with my premise. However as with your opinion I too hold an opinion and my opinion is that I have used pipe dope/sealant with good results. However in order to eliminate confusion for the person who is trying to seal his leak and to clarify my position: I use Rectorseal tplus2 sealant (
http://www.rectorseal.com/rectorseal-t-plus-2/). I used it due to the info about it: "RectorSeal® T Plus® is a non-hardening thread sealant containing PTFE
plus synthetic fibers. These fibers dispersed in a resinous base combined with inert mineral fillers provide maximum sealing performance. Its low coefficient of friction allows tighter joint makeup with lower torque. It also breaks out easily without galling, seizing, or damaging threads. It is excellent for service where immediate pressurization is necessary". So ultimately, it boils down to what people use and have success with. Some use Teflon tape, some use silicone, some probably rub dirt on the threads. Opinions vary and so do results. All I can do is offer my own experience which is- I've had good experience with the Tplus2 pipe sealant. Also it can be had at the local home despot or Ace hardware store and at $4 a tube it won't break the bank.