Rather than the "try this and if that doesn't work, try something else" syndrome, call:
The premier radiator supplier/repair facility is : GLEN-RAY
Glen-ray Radiators, Inc. • 2105 North 6th Street • Wausau, WI 54403 • PH: 800.537.3775
Restorationradiators.com
call them....he's expensive but worth the wait and cost. I spent ~ $ 1400 for the 26" max cool option; for a numbers matching radiator......his guarantee is excellent; quality is worth the cost .....IMO.....don't waste your time with an aluminum maybe it'll work radiator or what your "buddy" thinks ....... BOB RENTON