HAVING SECOND THOUGHTS ON USING REGULAR BATTS R-19 IN THE WALLS & R-38 IN THE VAULTED CEILINGS ON THE NEW GARAGE. ANY OPINIONS OUT THERE FOR USING SPRAY FOAM, OR OTHER ALTERNATIVE TO THE COMMON FIBERGLAS BATTS???
OPINIONS ON GARAGE INSULATION???
- Thread starter 8stackhemi
- Start date
You cant go wrong with batt insulation and proper venting. Thats what I did. r-40 in the ceiling with proper vents. r-19 in the 2 x 6 walls. Cool in the summer and easy to heat in the winter. I am not against foam as it does seal all drafts when done properly. You have to have all wall and ceiling wiring in place before foam.
I worry about issues with a wiring problem later on with the foam encapsulating it all. I have the 2x6 walls, too. Got a week or so before i pull the trigger.
I would get the foam done throughout and go with surface mounted wiring in EMT conduit inside. After all, it's a garage and how much wiring could be really be needed ?
I vote fiberglass for that reason. You can always take it loose and add plumbing or wiring. Blown-in is a turd to work with.
MoparLeo
NRA BENEFACTOR LEVEL LIFE MEMBER
- Local time
- 10:34 PM
- Joined
- Nov 24, 2015
- Messages
- 2,431
- Reaction score
- 2,612
- Location
- Moreno Valley, So California
Hard foam panels. Easy to handle. No fiberglas on you or in your lungs..
esub.com
Rigid Foam Insulation Pros and Cons
When it comes to building up a home’s insulation, rigid foam insulation is the preferred option. Here's a comparison of the different options.
esub.com
- Local time
- 12:34 AM
- Joined
- Aug 5, 2011
- Messages
- 3,799
- Reaction score
- 5,607
- Location
- Lisle, HELLinois!
I would totally wrap the inside of the garage with polyethylene sheeting, stapling it to every surface.
Then I would use the fiberglass batts because they have the most bang for your bucks. After that, I
would put 1/2" Thermax foam sheathing up before installing the drywall. Remember, you are not
building a house, so you shouldn't have any moisture issues! No bathing, (I hope!) no cooking, and
no humidifier. Seal it up like a bank vault and you won't have a large heating bill. My 24 X 24' garage
is insulated like this and the HOT DAWG heater goes on every three hours when it's zero degrees
outside and when I'm out there working the T-8 fluorescent light make enough heat that the heat
doesn't even come on. Sweet building! Wish I had the room.
Then I would use the fiberglass batts because they have the most bang for your bucks. After that, I
would put 1/2" Thermax foam sheathing up before installing the drywall. Remember, you are not
building a house, so you shouldn't have any moisture issues! No bathing, (I hope!) no cooking, and
no humidifier. Seal it up like a bank vault and you won't have a large heating bill. My 24 X 24' garage
is insulated like this and the HOT DAWG heater goes on every three hours when it's zero degrees
outside and when I'm out there working the T-8 fluorescent light make enough heat that the heat
doesn't even come on. Sweet building! Wish I had the room.
Actually, wiring is at the 93% completion stage right now, but that would have been an option, otherwise. I used radiant sheathing on the roof, but Lord knows if that will really be of any benefit after all is said & done.
Thanks! Do you mean, put the batts in, THEN WRAP with the polyethylene sheeting on the inside, stapling to the studs?? Then put the 1/2" Thermax on top of that? I'm planning on using Hardie Board T1-11 vertical panels on walls & vaulted ceiling, instead of drywall to give it a little pizzaz. Hope i'm not making a mistake there.
With my wiring already installed, the hard foam panels would be impossible between my stud & ceiling trusses, unless you're thinking something different?
Macdon221
Well-Known Member
Rockwool Bats. Higher r value. Easier to work with. Way better for fire compared to pink fiberglass.
Looks like you have some reflective rigid stuff up there already. I also see you are in South Carolina. How much insulation do you need? What is recommended for your area?
Coronet_Arch
Well-Known Member
Remember if you use foam it must be covered with drywall or wood as it is considered flammable.
- Local time
- 12:34 AM
- Joined
- Aug 5, 2011
- Messages
- 3,799
- Reaction score
- 5,607
- Location
- Lisle, HELLinois!
Put the poly up first for a killer vapor barrier, then the Batts, then the Thermax under your
finish material. Tape the seams on the Thermax!
finish material. Tape the seams on the Thermax!
I'm concerned more for Summers in Carolina! Super HOT & HUMID, especially July, August & into September. Soooo uncomfortably hot & humid, sometimes it feels unreal......especially after retiring here from MI. I'm putting in a Mini-Split system too, humidity & dampness is a bear down here!
Not sure how i put up poly, first! wrap it around & in between each 6" stud, then put the batts in??? Then put the Thermax over the studs before the finished interior wall? I'm confused,..........which can happen very easily, i might add!
Just ruled out the foam insulation, thanks!
- Local time
- 11:34 PM
- Joined
- Feb 22, 2013
- Messages
- 3,909
- Reaction score
- 5,070
- Location
- The Red Anvil Dog House
I think 8stack pretty much answered that question in post #9. No such thing as too much wiring. Looking good.
I'm fiberglass bat fan myself for the reasons stated above. My shop is R19 in the walls and R60 in the ceiling. I'm in Colorado where it get's to 100 degrees in the summer and 10 below in the winter.
The shop stays a nice 70 degrees in the summer with the doors closed. I keep the stats set at 55 in the winter when I'm not working out there and the heat rarely kicks on even on the coldest days.
The vaulted ceilings do present a bit of a twist. Perhaps a layer of bats then blow in on top of that?
Similar threads
