Hey there, I'm just jumping in here on page 29 so forgive me if I missed some details you may have covered. I did see that you have a 4 to 2 bolt adapter for the 2 bolt master cylinder. Was the pushrod in the booster extended enough to compensate for the adapter?
Factory type parts or aftermarket rotors/calipers, etc?
I read that the pedal is firm but the brakes are not satisfactory, right?
After years of multiple combinations, some of them terrible, some pretty good and now
excellent, I might be able to help.
The only time that I've had a
non power disc/drum system that had a firm pedal and poor braking, that car had a bad proportioning valve. I simply replaced it and didn't dig any deeper as to why the old one was bad. In retrospect, it could have been gunked up to the point where it wasn't flowing enough volume and the 4 corners were not getting adequate pressure.
In my red car, I tried a manual master cylinder setup a few times with these 4 wheel discs and while
again I had firm pedal and poor braking, a change
back to the power booster restored the braking force that I wanted. It wasn't the proportioning valve with this car.
The power booster could be bad. One test is to press the pedal a few times with the engine off. With your foot still on the pedal, start the engine. The pedal should sink a little but then equalize after lifting then pressing the pedal a couple of times.
Some brake pads and shoes do benefit from being "bedded in". I've only done that once though even though I've changed pads on my 400,000 mile truck numerous times without ever bedding in any of them. Same goes for every other brake pad or shoe swap that I've ever done. I suspect that this practice is probably limited to the higher performance race type pads.
In my experience, when the performance of a brake system changes for the worse, it comes down to a few things.
Contamination of the pads or shoes. Gear oil, wheel bearing grease, leaky wheel cylinder or caliper, etc.
Reduced pressure at the calipers or wheel cylinders due to leaks, blockages, corrosion or a bad master cylinder.
You can have a firm pedal and still have shitty brakes because the feel at the pedal is only representative of a system holding pressure.
A pressure gauge may be of use to you:
Front discs need 1200 or more, drums are okay with around 600.
Report back soon!