The Bullitt 68 Charger but with a Hemi.
A 68 R/T Hemi 4-speed, just the way you described it, would be the Charger for me. Second would be the same car with Sliver exterior.the rear window and 68 grille are what makes it for me. And the 68 TAILIGHTS!!!!!! I would probably take a 4 speed Hemi 68 with red guts and black exterior and a red rear stripe. If I was forced to think like myself (blue collar) and wanted to be honest I'd order a 383 4 speed 4 barrel with the same colors.
Let's say that you came into a large sum of money, and you have up say,250k to spend on your dream Charger, which one would you buy. Myself I would love to own that triple black 70 Charger R/T, Hemi 4 speed, sunroof car with the red tail stripe!