KD, did you select a water pump yet? That plate shown on the 6-blade pump is an anti-cavitation plate to minimize bubble formation and bubble formation is bad for cooling. One with a plate is best. The number of fins that is ideal depends on the water pump pulley diameter. In general, I've found the higher the fin count (with cavitation plate in place), the faster the coolant flow. I had an overheating issue on my 451 with all new parts and tracked it down to the speed of coolant flow. I went from a brand new 6-blade pump to a higher fin count brand new Flowkooler pump and the problem went away.
However, now that I'm about to install A/C which requires downsizing the water pump pulley , there's a chance that this new pump will move the water a bit TOO fast. I plan to test this and run that new setup with the high fin count pump. If the overheating returns, I'll swap back in the 6-blade pump and it should be good.
I spoke at length with the tech guys at Flowkooler about this. There's an old theory that big blocks or A/C cars got the lower fin count 6 blade pump to slow down the coolant and keep it in the rad longer for better cooling. This is not always true. It depends on what your motor needs and is highly dependent on the water pump pulley diameter.
Also, I know that you collect a lot of used parts and re-use them a lot. Water pumps are one thing that do wear out and need replacing. I would install a new pump if I were you. When my dad and I had the '67 Chevy 327, in the 43 years we owned it, we had to replace the water pump about 4 times. The bearings wear out. One way to test this is to carefully hold a metal rod (we used a tire iron) and place one end against the water pump housing and the other end to your ear with the motor running. A good pump will make a nice smooth whirring sound. You can hear the difference with a bad pump.
However, now that I'm about to install A/C which requires downsizing the water pump pulley , there's a chance that this new pump will move the water a bit TOO fast. I plan to test this and run that new setup with the high fin count pump. If the overheating returns, I'll swap back in the 6-blade pump and it should be good.
I spoke at length with the tech guys at Flowkooler about this. There's an old theory that big blocks or A/C cars got the lower fin count 6 blade pump to slow down the coolant and keep it in the rad longer for better cooling. This is not always true. It depends on what your motor needs and is highly dependent on the water pump pulley diameter.
Also, I know that you collect a lot of used parts and re-use them a lot. Water pumps are one thing that do wear out and need replacing. I would install a new pump if I were you. When my dad and I had the '67 Chevy 327, in the 43 years we owned it, we had to replace the water pump about 4 times. The bearings wear out. One way to test this is to carefully hold a metal rod (we used a tire iron) and place one end against the water pump housing and the other end to your ear with the motor running. A good pump will make a nice smooth whirring sound. You can hear the difference with a bad pump.